Best Peppadew Peppers Substitutes

Peppadew Peppers Substitutes

Best Peppadew Peppers Substitutes

With an excellent blend of sweet, spice, and everything nice—Peppadew peppers are commercially pickled to perfection, providing you with a distinct, tangy flavor unlike any other. They’re the best ingredients for pizza toppings, salads, sandwiches, antipasto, and more!

You can buy these peppers at your local supermarkets and grocery stores, specifically at the pickles or pickled pepper products section. However, you may have a hard time finding them as they can sell out fast. 

For you to be prepared when this happens here is a quick list of the easiest substitutes for Peppadew peppers

  • Jalapeño peppers
  • Pimentos
  • Sweet cherry peppers
  • Rocoto chiles
  • Pepperoncini
  • Giardiniera.

6 Of The Best Substitutes for Peppadew Peppers

Replicating the taste and texture of peppadew peppers is a hard task as it is very unique. It is important that you keep in mind what flavor profile you want to achieve when picking the most ideal substitute. Luckily, this article will help you with that.

Jalapeño peppers

When you want to turn up the heat in your dishes, Jalapeño peppers will hit the right spot. These peppers are readily available almost anywhere. So, when you’re in a hurry, this is a great substitute. 

Jalapeños, with their rich earthy taste, are perfect for sandwich and burger combos, toppings on nachos and pizzas, and can even be a great companion to your breakfast eggs. 

Make sure you get pickled Jalapeño peppers if you really want it to taste more similar to peppadew peppers. To achieve the same sweetness and balance the spice levels, drizzle a bit of honey according to your preference. 

Pimentos are great Alternative for PeppaDew
Pimentos are great Alternative for PeppaDew


Offering the same texture and a buttery aftertaste, Pimentos are great when your taste buds prefer little to no spice and more of the sweetness that peppadews have. 

Pimentos are commonly used as the main ingredients in Mediterranean cuisine such as caponatas, greek salads, and kebabs. They can level up your culinary experience when they’re chopped or sliced before adding them to your dishes. 

Take note that you may not achieve the same sweetness as Peppadews since Pimentos lean more on the savory side.  It is recommended that you add a little honey to better match the sweetness levels. 

Other chili substitute resources are

Sweet cherry peppers

This substitute is the most similar in terms of taste with Peppadew peppers. Sweet cherry peppers are versatile, ranging from sweet with a tangy undertone to mildly hot, perfect for a long list of dishes. 

Due to their versatility, sweet cherry peppers can be used in cheesesteaks and pastas, side dishes such as salads and crackers, and even for condiments such as dips and sauces. The possibilities are nearly endless with this one!

It only lacks a bit of sweetness, but nothing sugar or honey can’t fix! You can even try adding 1 tablespoon of white wine vinegar for every 5 peppers you use if you really want to fulfill that pickled taste. 

Rocoto chiles

Looking for a substitute to your homemade peppadew recipes? This one may be the best for you. Rocoto chiles come with a sweet and citrusy flavor but packed with more spice, so make sure you don’t go overboard or else you will suffer the fiery consequences of your actions!

Rocoto chiles are popular in Latin cuisine, specifically in Peruvian stuffed peppers, rellenos, stir-fries, rotisserie chickens, and even in dips and sauces. 

Remember to remove the seeds and membranes, and soak them overnight in water to avoid letting the spice overpower your dish. 



Don’t be fooled by their often green color, although they come in red too. They have the same mild but tangy taste as peppadews despite the differences in color. As an added bonus, they also provide you with a peppery aftertaste. 

Pepperoncini are popular peppers used to put in sandwiches, salads, stews, and can even serve as delicious toppings on pizzas. You can also try making crockpot dishes and skillets if you’re in a creative, experimental mood. 

Try perking up your recipes by adding some apple cider vinegar, water, and salt to really achieve a savory flavor and aroma. 


Finally, the only non-pepper substitute for peppadews. Giardiniera offers a sweet and tangy Italian mixture of pickled vegetables—usually carrots, celery, olives, and cauliflowers combined in a pickled brine. 

While it doesn’t exactly have a similar flavor profile with peppadews, they’re best used in salsas, relishes, and sandwiches, and work as pizza toppings too. What’s best is that they’re readily available in the canned vegetable section of your supermarket. 

To best enjoy giardiniera as a peppadew substitute, you may marinate it further in oil, salt, vinegar, or any other flavor enhancers you want to try before adding them to your recipes. 

How Do I Know Which Substitute I Should Go For?

Choosing a substitute is dependent on what you’re going to cook, what flavor you want to achieve, and how much you want them to resemble Peppadews. You may want to use them as stuffing vessels, toppings, or sandwich ingredients—you may prefer sweet and spicy or mild and tangy. 

Similar Posts